Collection: Best Sellers

Our Best Sellers Selection brings together the flavors our customers can’t stop talking about — the brownies and blondies that have earned their spot at the top. If you’re new to Buckabee Brownies, this is where to start. If you’re a longtime fan, these are the ones you come back for again and again.

At the heart of this lineup is our signature brownie: a perfect fudgy combination of rich Belgian chocolate and chocolate chip with that delicate, flaky top and irresistibly chewy, decadent center. From there, the favorites only get better — classic Chocolate Chip blondie, chewy and buttery and loaded with pockets of chocolate chips goodness. To continue, Ohio's classic buckeye is reimagined as our Peanut Butter Fudge brownie, making the perfect peanut-chocolate combo. Come and discover the rest of this collection of crowd-pleasers brownies and blondies.

Every piece is handmade in small batches using our original recipes — never processed, never from a mix, always crafted with the best ingredients.

This selection is perfect for gifts, nationwide shipping, catering, corporate events, office parties, brownie trays, and easy-to-send gift cards. Brownies travel better than cupcakes, are less messy than cookies, more affordable, and guaranteed to impress for every occasion.

When you want a sure thing — for celebrations, thank-yous, holidays, or just because — these are the flavors that never disappoint.